Baca› Kitab 3› Permintaan pria itu kepada Musa tentang bahasa hewan dan burung› Bait 3270
M3:3270 — گفت موسی رو گذر کن زین هوس / کاین خطر دارد بسی در پیش و پس
M3:3270
Makna · به زبانِ تو — Bahasamu · AI
The prophet Moses warns the man that his desire to know the language of animals is a dangerous whim that will lead to harm both now and in the future.
This couplet is the pivot point in the story, where the prophet's wisdom confronts the disciple's misguided desire. Moses identifies the man's request not as a noble spiritual quest, but as havas—a capricious whim or obsession driven by the ego (nafs). The danger, he warns, is total, encompassing both "what comes before and what comes after" (pish o pas). This suggests the desire's roots are corrupt and its fruits will be poisonous.
The man believes he is seeking spiritual insight ('ibrat), but Moses sees that the request itself is a symptom of spiritual impatience and a misunderstanding of how wisdom is acquired. True insight comes from God directly, not through esoteric tricks or shortcuts. The desire for a supernatural power like understanding animals is a classic spiritual pitfall in Sufi teaching: it mistakes a paranormal ability for genuine closeness to God. Moses's warning is a call to abandon the ego's desire for special knowledge and to instead pursue the more difficult, but safer, path of sincere devotion.
- هوس
- A whim, caprice, or ego-driven desire. In Sufi ethics, it is contrasted with 'himmat' (lofty spiritual aspiration) and is seen as a dangerous impulse of the lower self (nafs).
- گذر کن
- Literally "pass by." Idiomatically, it means to abandon, relinquish, or move on from something.
- پیش و پس
- Literally "before and after" or "front and back." An idiom signifying totality, encompassing all aspects of a situation—its origins, its present state, and its future consequences.
Discussion — Ask about this beyt — answered from the Masnavi, every verse cited
Your conversation stays on this device unless you share it.
What readers asked0
No questions shared yet — yours could be the first.