읽기› 권 5› 마지눈(Majnun)의 친척들이 그에게 말하길, 라일라(Layla)의 아름다움은 그렇게 대단치 않으며 우리 마을에 그녀보다 더 예쁜 여자가 많으니, 한 명, 두 명, 열 명을 보여줄 테니 선택하고 우리와 당신 자신을 놓아달라고 하자, 마지눈이 그들에게 답했다.› 대구 3288
M5:3288 — هست دریا خیمهای در وی حیات / بَطّ را، لیکن کلاغان را مَمات
M5:3288
의미 · به زبانِ تو — 당신의 언어 · AI
This couplet illustrates how the same external reality can be a source of life for some and death for others, depending on their inherent nature and disposition.
This beyt is part of Majnun's impassioned response to his relatives, who are trying to dissuade him from his love for Layli by claiming her beauty is ordinary and that there are many more beautiful women. Majnun argues that beauty is not an objective quality of the 'form' (صورت) but rather a subjective experience of the 'wine' (می) that God pours into one's heart through that form.
He uses the metaphor of the sea to explain this. For a duck (بطّ), which is naturally adapted to water, the sea is a life-giving environment, a 'tent' (خیمه) of existence. It provides sustenance and a home. However, for a crow (کلاغ), which is not a water bird, the very same sea would mean certain death. The sea itself doesn't change; what changes is the inherent nature of the creature encountering it. This perfectly mirrors Majnun's point about Layli: her physical form (the 'sea') is perceived differently by him (the 'duck') than by his relatives (the 'crows'). For him, she is the source of divine love and life, while for them, she is an ordinary woman, even a potential source of trouble or 'death' to their conventional understanding of love and life.
- بَطّ
- duck (a water bird)
- مَمات
- death, demise
Discussion — Ask about this beyt — answered from the Masnavi, every verse cited
Your conversation stays on this device unless you share it.
What readers asked0
No questions shared yet — yours could be the first.