Läs› Daftar 3› Berättelsen om en älskande med lång separation och många prövningar› Vers 4767
M3:4767 — بشنوی از قال های و هوی را / کی ببینی حالت صدتوی را
M3:4767
Betydelse · به زبانِ تو — Ditt språk · AI
This couplet explains that one can only perceive the superficial sounds and expressions of others, but never truly grasp the complex, hidden inner reality that drives those expressions.
This beyt comes in a section where Rumi is exploring the hidden nature of people's inner states, contrasting it with their outward appearances and actions. He uses the metaphor of a graveyard to illustrate that while all graves look similar on the surface (M3:4764), the 'agility' or inner experience of those buried within is vastly different. Similarly, the 'flesh and fat' of living people may appear the same, but one might be joyful while another is sorrowful (M3:4765). The preceding couplet (M3:4766) explicitly states that one cannot truly know another's inner state without 'drinking their words' (i.e., deeply understanding their expressions), because their true condition is hidden. This couplet then reinforces that idea: you only hear the 'hays and hoys' – the superficial sounds and exclamations – but you cannot see or understand the 'hundred-layered state' (حالت صدتوی) or the complex, multifaceted inner reality that gives rise to those sounds. It's a profound statement on the inherent unknowability of another's soul, emphasizing that outward manifestations are but a thin veil over deep, intricate spiritual and emotional landscapes.
- قال
- Outward speech, utterance, spoken word (often contrasted with 'حال', inner state).
- های و هوی
- A commotion, shouts, exclamations; here, refers to superficial or audible expressions.
- کی ببینی
- How can you see? / When will you see? (rhetorical, implying 'you cannot').
- حالت صدتوی
- The hundred-layered state; a complex, multifaceted, or deeply hidden inner condition.
Diskussion — Fråga om denna beyt — besvarad från Masnavi, med varje vers citerad
Ditt samtal stannar på denna enhet om du inte väljer att dela det.
Vad läsare har frågat0
Inga frågor har delats ännu — din kan bli den första.