پڑھیے› دفتر ۳› اس شخص کا موسیٰ علیہ السلام سے جانوروں اور پرندوں کی زبان کا مطالبہ› بیت ۳۲۷۷
M3:3277 — گر بیاموزم زیان کارش بود / ور نیاموزم دلش بد میشود
M3:3277
معنی و شرح · به زبانِ تو — آپ کی زبان · AI
Moses finds himself in a dilemma: teaching the man the language of animals will harm him, but refusing his insistent plea will make the man bitter and resentful.
This couplet captures the heart of Moses's predicament as he speaks to God. A man has obsessively pleaded to be taught the language of animals, a form of hidden knowledge. Moses, as a prophet, foresees that this knowledge will bring the man not wisdom, but ruin (ziyān). The man, however, is so fixated on his desire that he sees Moses's refusal not as a protective measure, but as a personal rejection from God's representative on earth.
Moses is caught between two negative outcomes. The first path—granting the wish—leads to the man's spiritual and worldly destruction, as he lacks the capacity to handle such power. The second path—denying the wish—will cause the man's heart to "go bad" (del-ash bad mi-shavad), meaning he will become resentful, lose faith, and turn away from the very prophet who is trying to save him. The beyt thus highlights a recurring theme in the Masnavi: the danger of spiritual gifts or powers when given to those who are not prepared for them, and the tragic inability of the spiritually immature to recognize true guidance when it contradicts their worldly desires.
- زیان کارش
- Literally 'his affair [will be] loss.' In this context, it means 'it will be to his detriment/ruin' or 'it will be a losing proposition for him.'
- دلش بد میشود
- Literally 'his heart becomes bad.' This idiom means he will become resentful, embittered, or hold a grudge.
Discussion — Ask about this beyt — answered from the Masnavi, every verse cited
Your conversation stays on this device unless you share it.
What readers asked0
No questions shared yet — yours could be the first.